TCCSP Frequently Asked Questions
Find answers to the most common questions about the Tulare County Carbon Storage Project (TCCSP). Learn more about how carbon capture and storage works, our partnership with the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE/NETL), and the role Calgren and other partners play in advancing clean energy solutions.
Carbon Capture and Sequestration 101
How deep underground will the CO₂ be stored and for how long? How do we know it will stay underground?
Permanent CO₂ storage occurs in deep saline formations composed of sandstones situated at least 3,000 feet below the surface and sealed by thick, continuous, impermeable shale caprocks. These caprocks ensure the CO₂ stays in lower formations, isolating it from any deep and shallow underground sources of drinking water. Carbon storage projects need to periodically monitor surface and subsurface conditions to ensure that injected CO₂ is stored securely underground.
How much CO₂ can an injection well inject? How do we know how much CO₂ can be injected and when the reservoir is full?
To assess how much CO₂ can be injected and held underground, modeling and monitoring techniques are employed to track CO₂ distribution and predict pressure buildup, allowing operators to adjust injection operations, as necessary. These assessments consider factors such as the reservoir’s size, capacity, permeability, and pressure limits, along with regulatory constraints.
Don’t we need CO₂?
CO₂ occurs naturally and is a necessary component of the carbon cycle where plants and organisms utilize it and recycle it. It is also produced from human activities such as energy production and transportation, but too much CO₂ in the atmosphere can have negative impacts, affecting the climate and human health and disturbing the carbon cycle. Currently, industries are producing CO₂ at a far higher rate than is being consumed. Therefore, there is an urgent need to capture the excess and remove it from the atmosphere to maintain a balance of the natural carbon cycle.
I’ve heard CCS is unproven technology. How long has carbon capture and storage (CCS) been taking place in the US and elsewhere?
CO₂ has been injected and stored underground, in some form or another, in the U.S. for over 50 years. Since the early 1970’s, CO₂ has been injected into deep subsurface formations to recover fossil fuels. This is still the case in West Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi, Wyoming, and Montana. These operations paved the way for CO₂ compression, transport, storage and injection infrastructure which form the basis for CCS design operations. Dedicated CO₂ storage in non-oilfield settings started in Norway in the late 1990’s. Millions of tons of CO₂ have since been safely stored for decades in deep, underground geologic formations.
What is the difference between CCS and CCUS involving EOR?
CCS focuses on capturing CO₂ emissions and storing them deep underground in geological formations to prevent them from entering the atmosphere and contributing to climate change. CCUS includes an extra step: after capturing CO₂, it can be used for things like Enhanced Oil Recovery (EOR), where CO₂ is injected into old oil fields to obtain more oil before being permanently stored.
Monitoring and Safety
What are the monitoring requirements of CCS?
The monitoring requirements for a CO₂ injection well start before injection commences and include a variety of methods to monitor and protect public health and drinking water sources. Monitoring methods required by the U.S. EPA for CCS projects include pressure monitoring, fluid sampling, CO₂ plume tracking, and a variety of underground leak-detection monitoring wells, among others.
What safety plans will be in place for CSS projects to monitor seismicity and the potential for leaks?
Safety plans for CCS projects are comprehensive and designed to monitor and detect any potential leaks, ensuring the integrity of storage reservoirs and safeguarding the surrounding environments. These plans incorporate various measures, including seismic monitoring and modeling techniques to assess reservoir stability, detect leaks, and predict responses to CO₂ injection, helping to identify potential risks.
What measures will you take to protect the integrity of the cement casings used for CO₂ injection during climate disasters, especially if water infiltrates them?
To protect cement casings in injection wells, it is essential to ensure proper design and installation, using high-quality materials and precise cementing techniques. Regular inspections and pressure tests will help detect issues early, while corrosion protection measures and continuous well integrity monitoring can prevent deterioration. Routine maintenance and adherence to regulatory standards will ensure the casing remains in good condition, and an emergency response plan will address any potential failures or leaks. These practices collectively ensure the long-term safety and effectiveness of the well.
How will you ensure that you will take responsibility in case there is a problem with your technology, instead of abandoning the community as has happened in other cases?
This project is equipped with multiple monitoring systems designed to prevent issues before they arise, along with a comprehensive emergency response plan to effectively manage any potential risks. This plan ensures that any concerns related to the project are addressed promptly, following established protocols and involving the appropriate authorities to prioritize community and environmental health. As part of this project, we will submit semi-annual reports to the EPA on the monitoring systems and the data collected, ensuring transparency and accountability. As the facility operator, Calgren is committed to protecting public health and improving safety. Since 2008, Calgren has placed a strong emphasis on the well-being of local communities, while also spearheading efforts in sustainability and energy efficiency. The Calgren Renewable Fuels facility has gone nearly four years – 1,400 days – without a workplace accident. This dedication to safety, along with their swift response to emergencies and corrective actions, underscores their responsibility to both the community and the environment.
Impact on Natural Resources
How does CCS impact natural resources, including forests and farms?
CCS projects impact natural resources and land use primarily during the construction phase. Project infrastructure such as pipelines and well pads will require some temporary land clearing and disturbing. Project design and construction activities must factor in local land use and protected areas while ensuring local air and water quality impacts are negligible compared to baseline. The overall impact CCS project infrastructure and operations have on natural resources such as forests and farms are minimal.
Will CCS impact soils near the surface and how can this be monitored?
Leakage of CO₂ from storage reservoirs or injection wells, while rare, could affect soils and nearby ecosystems. Surface monitoring is used to assess soil conditions and vegetation health, while gas monitoring is used to detect CO₂ leaks. Remote sensing can also be utilized to track changes in land cover, and groundwater monitoring can also be used to assess water quality.
Will CCS projects take up agricultural land and lead to job loss of farm workers?
CCS project infrastructure will require some temporary land clearing and disturbance. Permanent structures will have a much smaller footprint comparatively. Project designs consider land use and typically targets land that is not actively being farmed or supporting local jobs. The development of CCS projects may create employment opportunities in areas such as construction, engineering, and maintenance.
How can you assure us that the project will not contaminate our land, drinking water, and groundwater, considering the existing pollution from pesticides and existing operations?
To prevent contamination of land, drinking water, and groundwater, we will implement several measures. We will conduct thorough environmental assessments to identify and mitigate risks, use advanced containment technologies to prevent leaks, and adhere to strict safety and regulatory standards. Regular monitoring and testing will be carried out to detect any issues early, with a comprehensive remediation plan in place for swift response to any contamination. We will also keep the community informed and address any concerns that may arise. There will be minimal disturbances to the natural resources surrounding the project, and the overall reduction in CO₂ emissions will benefit surrounding communities in the long run.
Carbon Capture and Sequestration Risks and Hazards
What are the potential risks associated with the project, and how will they be mitigated? Are there any anticipated environmental impacts?
Any CCS project comes with potential risks such as CO₂ leakage, induced seismicity, and well integrity issues. To mitigate these risks, we will use advanced sealing technologies, robust monitoring systems, and rigorous safety measures. The storage site has been carefully selected to minimize environmental impact, with comprehensive assessments and ongoing monitoring that will be in place to detect and address issues early. While CCS projects can significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions and aid climate change mitigation, it also involves potential negative impacts like land use changes, habitat disruption, groundwater contamination, and increased energy requirements. We will address these concerns through careful site selection, environmental assessments, continuous monitoring, and adherence to regulatory standards to ensure safe and effective implementation.
How will you ensure that the liquid CO₂ will not escape from the injection infrastructure in case of a flood, considering that septic tanks, which are also cement structures, tend to overflow during heavy rains?
To prevent liquid CO₂ from escaping the injection infrastructure during a flood, we will employ several measures including monitoring methods as required by the U.S. EPA. The infrastructure will be designed and constructed to withstand extreme weather, with elevated placement and flood barriers to mitigate water impact. We will use advanced sealing technologies and reinforce structures to prevent leaks. Continuous monitoring methods include pressure monitoring, fluid sampling, CO₂ plume tracking, and a variety of underground leak-detection monitoring wells, among others will be used to monitor the site. Regular maintenance will ensure system integrity, and a comprehensive emergency response plan will be in place to manage potential flooding events and coordinate with local emergency services.
Pipeline Safety
Addressing pipeline safety – will what happened in Satartia, MS, happen again?
In 2020, a CO₂ pipeline ruptured near Satartia, Mississippi due to a landslide caused by weeks of heavy rain. The leak resulted in non-fatal injuries and a careful re-examination of the current regulations and guidelines for CO₂ pipeline construction and operation. PHMSA has drafted rigorous standards for CO₂ pipelines, including requirements related to emergency preparedness, notification, and response. These standards are currently under review by USDOT. Pipeline operators are responsible for working with local emergency responders, creating emergency response plans, and working with the public to increase awareness.
I’ve heard that the transportation of CO₂ isn’t safe. Is that true?
Transporting CO₂ by truck, rail, or pipeline is safe and highly regulated and monitored. Truck and rail are common and safe methods of transportation, while pipelines serve as a more efficient method. Under the U.S. Department of Transportation (USDOT) and the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA), CO₂ pipelines must specifically adhere to rigorous guidelines. There are regulations and requirements in place for the safe operation of these pipelines and the emergency preparedness and response plans required for them. Moreover, it is the duty of the project developers to work closely with local first responders to ensure the safe transportation of CO₂ and emergency preparedness.
Carbon Capture and Sequestration Project Funding
What kind of funding is there for CCS projects?
Funding for CCS projects can come from various sources, including government grants, private investment, and public-private partnerships. An example of government funding for CCS projects is the Carbon Storage Assurance Facility Enterprise (CarbonSAFE) Initiative. Funded through the President’s Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, this initiative helps enhance CO₂ storage infrastructure to decrease emissions effectively and responsibly from industrial activities, power generation, and historical emissions in the atmosphere.
How can the funding for CCS projects impact communities?
Funding from programs such as the CarbonSAFE Initiative offers advantages to communities by creating avenues for involvement in project execution, potential employment opportunities for residents, and extensive prospects for economic growth to enhance local economies. In addition, funding these projects can help address environmental issues that are present in the project areas and provide solutions.
Community Benefits, Impacts, and Jobs
Who will be eligible for the jobs stemming from the project? How might they be trained?
Eligibility for these jobs is dependent on the type of job and the experience they may require. At this stage, the types of jobs that will be available and the quantity is still being determined.
Who are you working with to ensure that proper education and training is available for locals wanting to have that job?
The project team is having collaborative discussions with the Livermore Lab Foundation to develop a classroom program on climate change and removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere with the Pixley School District and potentially local colleges. This program will help high school and college students understand what CCS is and how it works, laying the groundwork for those interested in pursuing related careers.
What actions will you take to ensure that local communities are not negatively affected by this project?
To ensure that local communities are not negatively impacted by this project, we will maintain transparent communication by keeping the community well-informed about construction and monitoring activities through regular updates and meetings. Additionally, we will implement continuous monitoring of the project’s processes to ensure safety and promptly address any issues that arise. Strict safety protocols will also be established and adhered to, minimizing potential risks and ensuring that the community remains protected throughout the project.
What specific measures will you take to prevent bringing more diseases, health complications from pollution, and environmental conditions to the Valley with this project? For example, improvements to air quality, etc.?
To prevent introducing diseases, health complications from pollution, and adverse environmental conditions in the Central Valley, we will implement several key measures. We will use advanced technologies and best practices to control and minimize emissions and dust pollution, ensuring that air quality is maintained or improved, with regular monitoring and maintenance. Comprehensive health and safety protocols will protect both workers and the community, including proper waste management and contamination prevention measures. Continuous environmental monitoring will track and address any potential impacts on soil, water, and air quality, with regular testing and assessments to ensure compliance with environmental standards. We will also engage openly with the community, providing updates and addressing concerns to keep everyone informed about our safeguards. Additionally, we will adhere to all local, state, and federal regulations to ensure the project operates within established safety and environmental guidelines. These actions aim to protect the Valley from any negative effects and contribute positively to the community’s well-being.
Status of TCCSP
Is this facility a done deal or is it still TBD?
The project is currently assessing its feasibility based on the geological conditions revealed by the research well and feedback from the community. The EPA will make the final decision on whether the project advances to the injection phase.
What determines whether it moves forward?
The continuation of the project relies on assessing its feasibility after analyzing data from the test well. The final decision on whether the project proceeds to the injection phase is made by the EPA.
How long does the community have to give input on the project?
The community has the opportunity to give input on the project throughout the whole lifecycle of the project. Questions or concerns? Contact us at tccsp@adv-res.com.